Depending on where you are located... In my area of Western North Carolina Verizon is THE DEAL as far as total coverage and signal strength. I'm not a real big phone person, have very little texting needs and no use for data. As I tell people, "it's just a phone, it rings, I answer, say what needs to be said and say good bye". So in my case I found a Verizon prepaid plan that works perfectly. 500 minutes of outgoing airtime, unlimited incoming, unlimited text and unlimited mobile web (sometimes useful) for $35 a month. Set the account up on an auto pay so that it renews each month and you're done. Unless you are into long phone conversations (which I personally hate) 500 minutes (about 8 1/2 hours) is more than enough.
Have you looked into ClubCellular?
They use the Verizon network and their prices on phones and plans seem reasonable (very similar to Consumer Cellular).
I am trying to find out what the quality of customer service is for ClubCellular.